
How to choose an SEO company: 8 questions before you sign
By Leonel Rocha · Product Designer
· 6 min read
Choose an SEO company by its answers, not its promises. Ask for past work, ask whether it follows Google's rules, what results it expects and when, and how it measures them. Be wary of guaranteed top rankings and link packages: Google has already run four spam updates in 2026, and you are the one accountable for what's done on your site.
Choose an SEO company by its answers, not its promises. Ask for past work, ask whether it follows Google's rules, what results it expects and when, and how it measures them. Be wary of guaranteed top rankings and link packages: Google has already run four spam updates in 2026, and you are the one accountable for what's done on your site.
- 4
- Google spam updates in 2026, through October, according to the official status dashboard
- 13 days
- was how long the September 2026 spam update lasted, from 9/24 to about 10/7
- 3
- access levels in Search Console: owner, full user, and restricted user
Hiring SEO means hiring someone to work on the asset that brings customers to your company without you paying per click. If the work is good, your site shows up for people already searching for what you sell. If it's bad, your site can drop in the results or vanish from them, and Google won't accept the excuse that it was the provider's fault.
The risk isn't theoretical. According to the official Google Search status dashboard, 2026 has already had four spam updates (March, June, August, and September) and two core ranking updates. The latest spam update started on September 24 and took about 13 days to finish, ending in October. Each one is a test of what was done on your site. Below are the questions that separate a serious SEO company from one that will send you the bill later.
What an SEO company does, according to Google
Google keeps an official page for people about to hire, called Do you need an SEO?, updated in June 2026. It lists what a good professional delivers:
- Review of the site's content and structure.
- Technical advice: hosting, redirects, error pages, use of JavaScript.
- Content creation and campaign management.
- Keyword research and training for your team.
- Knowledge of the market and region where you sell.
- Generative AI optimization, meaning showing up in AI answers.
That last item matters more every day. In 2026, some searchers get a ready-made answer, on Google or ChatGPT, before they see any link. An SEO company that doesn't mention this in its proposal is only working half of search.
The 8 questions to ask before you sign

The first three come straight from Google's page. The other five are the ones I'd ask before letting anyone touch a client's site.
1. Can you show me past work?
Google suggests asking for examples and success stories. Go beyond the slide deck: ask for the site addresses and search the terms the company claims to rank for yourself. Also ask how long it has been in business and whether it has worked with companies in your industry and region.
2. Do you follow Google's guidelines?
The question seems obvious, but the answer reveals a lot. Anyone who follows Search Essentials, Google's official set of rules, explains what they'll do without hedging. Anyone who changes the subject is probably using something they don't want to describe.
3. What results do you expect, and when?
Google advises asking exactly this, along with “how do you measure success?”. A good answer talks about leads, quote requests, and sales coming from search. A weak answer only talks about keyword rankings. For a realistic benchmark before the conversation, see how long it takes for a site to show up on Google.
4. What exactly will you change on my site?
Google warns against companies that are “secretive” or don't clearly explain what they intend to do. The reason is simple: the official page reminds you that you remain responsible for what the provider does on your site. Ask for the list of changes in writing, month by month.
5. Do you buy or trade links?
Google's spam policies, updated in August 2026, define link spam as creating links “primarily for the purpose of manipulating ranking”. Buying or selling links for that purpose is on the list of examples. A package sold by volume, like “100 backlinks a month”, is your cue to end the conversation.
6. Will you mass-produce pages with AI?
The same policy treats generating many pages, with AI or not, mainly to manipulate search as scaled content abuse. Content written with AI assistance isn't banned. The problem is volume with no value for the reader. Ask who reviews it, who understands your business, and how many pages go up each month.
7. What access do you need?
Search Console, Google's free tool that shows how your site appears in search, has three permission levels: owner, full user, and restricted user. Only the owner controls everything and can add or remove people. A full user can already, for example, request URL removals. A restricted user can only view most of the data. Google recommends granting read-only access for an audit. The owner account always stays in your company's name.
8. What happens if I leave?
Ask about the minimum contract term, what you keep at the end (copy, reports, access), and whether any change made to the site depends on the company's paid tool to keep working. If the answer is “the content is ours”, you're renting your own site.
The red flags Google tells you to avoid
Beyond the questions, Google's official page lists warning signs that work as a quick filter:
- Guaranteed rankings. In Google's words: “No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google”. If someone guarantees it, look elsewhere.
- A “special relationship” with Google. It doesn't exist.
- Out-of-the-blue emails offering SEO.
- A “Google-approved” tool. Google tells you to be wary of that pitch.
- A request to link to the SEO company from your site.
Getting this wrong is costly. According to the spam policies, sites that break the rules can rank lower or not appear at all, through automated systems or human review. After a manual action, you have to fix everything and request a new review from Google, and that time is time with no customers coming in from search.
Low price, high price: what to really compare
Two SEO proposals at the same price can deliver completely unrelated work. One fixes the technical foundation and writes the pages your customers search for. The other sends a rankings report every month and nothing changes on the site. Before comparing the final number, compare what's included: who writes, how many pages, whether fixes are made or just recommended, how results are measured. Market ranges and what drives the price are in how much SEO costs a business per month.
There's one more question almost nobody asks: can your current site handle SEO? If it's slow, doesn't work well on mobile, or was built in a way Google reads poorly, the first months of fees go to repairs. Google says the best time to hire is when you're thinking about rebuilding the site, and the sooner the better, so it launches ready for search.
How we do it at the Studio
At the Studio, SEO and GEO start at the site's foundation, not with a monthly report fee. The custom-coded sites we build ship with structured data, a sitemap, llms.txt, and access for AI to read the content from day one. That's how studioresponsivo.com.br itself works, in Portuguese, English, and Spanish, with a blog that publishes every day. The sales page conversaovisual.com.br scored 99 out of 100 on Lighthouse, Google's measurement tool, in October 2026.
The fixed price is set after discovery, and the deadline is written into the contract. Code, files, domain, and access, including Search Console ownership, stay in the client's name. We use Figma and Claude Code for design and build, with our in-house dev team. We've done 600+ projects since 2014, in 13 countries.
If you want your company to show up for people already looking for what you sell, on Google and in AI answers, start with an audit of your site through the Studio's SEO and GEO service.
Common questions
Can an SEO company guarantee first place on Google?
No. Google itself says no one can guarantee the top spot and advises finding another provider if someone makes that promise. What you can agree on is the work delivered and how results will be measured.
What access should I give an SEO company?
For an audit, read access to Search Console is enough. The account stays in your company's name, as the owner. Edit access to the site and to Search Console only when agreed work actually requires it.
If the SEO company does something wrong, who is accountable?
You are. Google makes it clear that the site owner is responsible for what the provider does on it. A site that violates the spam policies can drop in the results or disappear from them entirely.
When is the best time to hire SEO?
Before you build or rebuild the site. Google recommends hiring as early as possible in a redesign, so the site launches ready for search instead of paying later to fix the foundation.
Sources
Related service
Websites
Company websites in code, fast, found on Google and cited by AI
News Responsivo
Get the next article in your inbox
Cost, timelines, AI and behind the scenes of shipping products. No spam.


